a quaint new england town at dusk

Question 3

[Content notes: politics, capital punishment. I started this a while ago so it is not a commentary on any specific recent events. It’s more of an ongoing mood.]


in ,

Comments

9 responses to “Question 3”

  1. Hehehe, this is funny in a AAARGH sort of way.

    1. Thank you, it came from a place of AAARGH.

  2. Random Avatar

    Hm, tricky. I think I’d vote “no”, but it’s definitely a conundrum. There’s the joy of the community will take in seeing her cut to pieces, versus the loss of her joy that will be ended with her life. Both these things have tremendous value. I suppose you could compromise- cut her with knives until she’s merely seriously injured- but that would please neither party, I think. Overall, the imposition on the individual would be greater than that on the community, although it would be a close thing. So, again, I’d vote “no”, but I can certainly see the other side.

    1. I approved your comment, but… with reservations.

  3. Roxolan Avatar

    Frankly, I think putting the question to a referendum in the first place was misguided. This is a proposal that does not affect a significant number of Marbury residents and does not require expenditure of Marbury public funds (besides a negligible amount if the council does not own the right kind of knife), so why on Earth is it OUR call? Are we going to vote on what color sticky notes the mayor should use next? The decision should’ve been left to our democratically elected officials, who have the time and expertise to navigate the pros and cons.

  4. I read this entire piece out to my partner while we were waiting for the bus, and afterwards we were silent. Just…beautifully brutal writing, in a way that highlights how politics can be dehumanizing and also miss the point on….why things were decided in the first place.

    That whole “some people have to die for democracy to function” mindset is so poisonous.

  5. Spot on, extremely well written. Oddly enough, the least believable portion of this was reading the results for Question 4. When I was doing school advocacy, any material support for a school that didn’t involve a football field upgrade would typically immediately devolve into discourse around public/private schools. “What is a safe playground, anyway? We’re coddling today’s children.” “More city handouts, we need equal treatment for private and charter schools, pillars of our community.” “More money goes to woke schooling.” “Now that you mention it, we should close the school entirely instead because of their awful academic performance” (unsubstantiated claim), etc.

    1. My town is “socially liberal, fiscally conservative” so what they do is vote for the school improvements, but then vote against the tax raise that would fund these improvements, hoping that this will be resolved by the Money Fairy.

      (Also, the pickleball thing is non-fiction. People got viciously NIMBY about this pickleball court. I don’t play pickleball so whatever, but oh my god you people)

  6. That was a genuinely stunning piece of literature. Really, really well done.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *